Electric Car – the first six weeks

by Roger Harmer on 22 April, 2011

I’ve now had my Tata Vista EV electric car for 6 weeks. I’m taking part in a national trial of electric cars, which includes around 300 drivers trialling many different makes and models over a year of normal driving. The following are my main thoughts on the trial so far:

1) The biggest issue in getting used to driving the car were the mundane differences from my ‘convential’ car (a Focus) in particular the indicator and wash/wipe being on the opposite sides of the steering column. In other words it feels very normal, easy (its very similar to an automatic) and un-querky to drive.

2) When you talk  to people about it, almost everyone asks you whether you are worried about running out of charge. My standard answer now is ‘no more than I worry about running out of diesel in my Focus’. I use it around town, going to Council meetings, doing the shopping, being a taxi driver for the kids etc, and have done around 200 miles a week in it, since picking it up. In this time I have never gone below 50% charge on the battery. I simply plug it in at home every night (very easy to do) and its fully recharged the next morning.

3) I also use public charging points when I am able to. Conveniently there is one near the Council House, in Margaret Street – as the following picture of my car, being charged, shows:

My Tata Vista EV at a public charging point

4) This did have a slight downside when someone tried to steal the cable from the car – luckily the plug is locked into the charging point so they didn’t succeed, but they did damage the charging point so only one of the two in Margaret Street is currently working (it should be repaired within a couple of weeks). I do think they need to find a way of locking the cable into the car when its being charged to limit the risk of this being repeated.

5) The cost equation is interesting. My rough maths says it costs me around 3p a mile around town, in terms of fuel (electricity). Compare that with  a fairly economical conventional car (my diesel Focus does about 9 miles per litre of diesel in town, which equates to just  over 15p a mile). So there is a huge saving. But there needs to be to offset the up front cost of the battery. At my use I’m saving about £1,200 a year in fuel, but the battery cost (£9k ish) will more than outweigh that for the present. If it comes down to £7k which I’m told is possible and a time expired battery (4 years) can be resold (it still has 80% of its charge capacity at this point and might be useful as a source of temporary back up electricity supply) for say £3k, you are getting to a point where the economics works, at my level of use. In case you are wondering, I also pay a monthly hire charge during the trial, which, taking into account a saving in wear and tear on my old car, probably leaves me about equal on the deal.

5) A big benefit of the car, especially using it around town as I do, is the environmental benefit of being zero emission. This weekend we are being asked to only drive if really necessary due to smog caused by the still and warm weather. Not that this stops many people driving, and as a result the smog is a major health hazard. I, however can feel relatively guilt free about driving as my car produces no emissions (directly), and the difference is significantly marked when set against a diesel car, which while generally producing less CO2, also tend to have much higher levels of particulates in their emissions which make the smog much worse. Its true that the portion of the electricity I use that comes from coal and gas does itself produce emissions at the power station, but its only a portion, its significantly lower in terms of energy use per mile and those power station emissions I am responsible for, are further from people than if I produced them in a conventional car.

 6) Finally, there have just been two occasions when I’ve not been able to use the electric car, due to its limited range, for a journey I needed to make. Both journeys were around 110 miles, well beyond the 85 miles or so range of the car. I used my old car, which I’m keeping, to go back to after the trial ends. If I didn’t have it, I’d had to have hired a car or gone by train (which would be my preferred option but was difficult for both journeys). Its clearly a big limitation on wider take up for electric cars (though they are fine as a second car for cities). However its interesting that its only been an issue in 2 journeys in 6 weeks, much less than I’d have guessed before the trial started. I’ll do my best to minimise the use of my Focus during the trial and will note how this goes.

I’ll give another update around the end of May, but if anyone has any questions I’m happy to answer them.

   2 Comments

2 Responses

  1. Nonconformistradical says:

    “A big benefit of the car, especially using it around town as I do, is the environmental benefit of being zero emission.”

    So how is the electricity generated? Probably from fossil fuel? Which means that although the vehicle may not be polluting in terms of exhaust fumes there is still a greenhouse gas cost

  2. rogerharmer says:

    Yes there is a greenhouse gas cost, as the post says. However its less than a conventional car and has the possibility of declining radically as electricity is decarbonised, hence the interest in investigating the technology via the trial.

Leave a Reply

You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>